1 00:00:11,962 --> 00:00:13,547 Thank you, thank you. 2 00:00:14,831 --> 00:00:16,717 That's what happens when you give a lot of B's. 3 00:00:17,038 --> 00:00:18,062 You get very popular. 4 00:00:19,928 --> 00:00:22,596 Tough A, but an easy B. 5 00:00:22,981 --> 00:00:29,872 Now my genuflection to my age comes out with my $2.99 ocean state job lot glasses. 6 00:00:30,814 --> 00:00:32,798 Okay. 7 00:00:33,153 --> 00:00:34,615 I'm delighted to be here. 8 00:00:34,640 --> 00:00:38,733 I wrote it out so I wouldn't digress too terribly much, 9 00:00:38,758 --> 00:00:42,313 but we'll have chance for conversation afterwards. 10 00:00:42,353 --> 00:00:43,695 I can't give just a lecture. 11 00:00:43,735 --> 00:00:46,980 This really is a condensation of a 13-week semester. 12 00:00:46,960 --> 00:00:49,425 This one would be called Science, Faith, and Religion. 13 00:00:50,086 --> 00:00:57,360 Science, Faith, Society, and Religion, if it were a 13-week course, and it is a reasonable topic for a 13-week course. 14 00:00:58,061 --> 00:00:59,123 Welcome back to school. 15 00:01:00,065 --> 00:01:06,758 I mean that in a very literal sense out of respect for people who are closer to my age than your children are. 16 00:01:06,738 --> 00:01:12,954 Many of whom were born in 1988, my 14 freshmen advisees this semester were all born 17 00:01:12,978 --> 00:01:19,194 in 1988, which, if you want to do the arithmetic, makes me 54 years older than they are. 18 00:01:19,454 --> 00:01:27,092 And that is a huge gap in memory, and it makes the challenge for me as a teacher every year harder and 19 00:01:27,116 --> 00:01:34,753 more and more formidable, but it's some of the fact that I have to live with that I was born in 1934. 20 00:01:34,733 --> 00:01:41,884 You're here, of course, to see them, to love them, to make certain that their intellectual and personal growth is moving forward. 21 00:01:42,424 --> 00:01:49,755 But you're also here to share with them that experience of teaching and learning that joins us together in this enterprise. 22 00:01:50,136 --> 00:01:52,559 Somebody asked me coming in, when do we take the exam? 23 00:01:52,940 --> 00:01:55,003 You don't have to worry about exams. 24 00:01:55,473 --> 00:02:01,852 But we hope that you return to work and home in a few days with a renewed sense of curiosity that will 25 00:02:01,876 --> 00:02:08,255 drive you back to libraries, to books, and to that wonderful techno tool of the devil, the Internet. 26 00:02:09,337 --> 00:02:15,668 I confess, I Google at least five times a day, and I challenge Wikipedia almost as often. 27 00:02:16,209 --> 00:02:19,455 The Internet has changed our lives as teachers. 28 00:02:19,435 --> 00:02:20,597 It's made us better teachers. 29 00:02:20,697 --> 00:02:22,600 It's made us more accessible teachers. 30 00:02:23,021 --> 00:02:26,026 It's made us more accessible to our students and our years. 31 00:02:26,647 --> 00:02:27,668 I say this every year. 32 00:02:28,089 --> 00:02:31,234 What is it called after four years, the event that they go to at the end? 33 00:02:32,316 --> 00:02:33,297 Some say graduation. 34 00:02:33,337 --> 00:02:34,820 I say it's not called graduation. 35 00:02:35,501 --> 00:02:36,502 It's called commencement. 36 00:02:36,803 --> 00:02:38,085 What does commencement mean? 37 00:02:39,095 --> 00:02:40,256 It's the beginning. 38 00:02:40,611 --> 00:02:41,933 It's the beginning for them. 39 00:02:41,958 --> 00:02:45,883 If they only added up to what they learned in the four years, that's not enough. 40 00:02:46,403 --> 00:02:47,404 So it is the beginning. 41 00:02:47,745 --> 00:02:51,769 And now we are connected in a way that really is quite remarkable. 42 00:02:52,610 --> 00:02:53,972 My students keep at me. 43 00:02:54,112 --> 00:02:55,834 You pay four years of tuition for them. 44 00:02:56,114 --> 00:02:57,236 You get 40 back. 45 00:02:57,556 --> 00:02:58,857 You get everything that you want. 46 00:02:58,917 --> 00:03:02,862 Your students, the teachers, your kids are in class with us forever after they go. 47 00:03:03,242 --> 00:03:07,347 And you also can join them in that experience. 48 00:03:07,327 --> 00:03:11,128 My task today is to set the stage and the tone for the lectures, 49 00:03:11,152 --> 00:03:15,317 discussions, and dialogue you'll experience over the next 48 hours. 50 00:03:15,418 --> 00:03:16,038 We have a theme. 51 00:03:17,140 --> 00:03:24,349 My hope is that these next two days will lead you to your own semester of subjects, questions, and perhaps some answers. 52 00:03:24,990 --> 00:03:29,822 But don't leave here this weekend without at least five email addresses 53 00:03:29,846 --> 00:03:33,862 of faculty whom you will be contacting whenever you want them. 54 00:03:34,242 --> 00:03:38,248 As I said, you pay already, or you pay for four years of tuition. 55 00:03:38,669 --> 00:03:41,473 Your kids will have access for the rest of their lives. 56 00:03:41,934 --> 00:03:42,995 Don't forget this. 57 00:03:43,135 --> 00:03:46,560 It's a new phenomenon, a new way of learning, and your learning keeps up. 58 00:03:46,621 --> 00:03:53,127 I just had one of my students, who now runs a hedge fund in Yugoslavia 59 00:03:53,452 --> 00:03:58,058 who had 15 new people into his hedge fund, and he said, would you come online 60 00:03:58,238 --> 00:04:04,870 and talk to these 15 people about what they're going to experience in investing in Yugoslavia. 61 00:04:05,111 --> 00:04:05,932 I said, well, what do they know? 62 00:04:06,033 --> 00:04:08,798 They know nothing about Yugoslavia. 63 00:04:08,818 --> 00:04:12,825 And remind me of the small op-ed piece that appeared in the New York Times. 64 00:04:13,166 --> 00:04:14,148 I already am digressing. 65 00:04:14,508 --> 00:04:17,442 Appeared in the New York Times just three days ago 66 00:04:17,466 --> 00:04:20,820 that says the difference between a Sunni and a Shia. 67 00:04:20,800 --> 00:04:25,370 And in that op-ed piece, it said, you know, too many people in American 68 00:04:25,394 --> 00:04:28,693 government don't know the difference between a Sunni and a Shia. 69 00:04:28,794 --> 00:04:33,402 Well, our generation wouldn't have known the difference between a Sunni and a Shia if we fell over them. 70 00:04:33,422 --> 00:04:34,804 We knew nothing about Islam. 71 00:04:35,165 --> 00:04:35,806 We knew nothing. 72 00:04:35,946 --> 00:04:37,529 We were not educated to know that. 73 00:04:37,709 --> 00:04:45,159 Now it's a different world, and that material has to be accessible and available to us, and you have to get it when you have to get it. 74 00:04:45,399 --> 00:04:47,442 Our students will be in not bad shape. 75 00:04:47,682 --> 00:04:48,784 Some of you may need to. 76 00:04:49,064 --> 00:04:56,914 The young hedge fund operator in Yugoslavia, I get online with those 15 people, and I said, what are you dealing with? 77 00:04:56,934 --> 00:04:59,137 You're dealing, where are you going to invest? 78 00:04:59,157 --> 00:05:03,943 We're going to invest in Serbia, we're going to invest in Croatia, we're going to invest in Bosnia. 79 00:05:04,264 --> 00:05:05,566 Do you know anything about these people? 80 00:05:05,606 --> 00:05:06,687 What are the Serbians? 81 00:05:06,712 --> 00:05:07,433 They're Serbians. 82 00:05:07,488 --> 00:05:08,991 I said, no, what's their religion? 83 00:05:09,332 --> 00:05:09,833 Who cares? 84 00:05:10,955 --> 00:05:11,716 I said, they care. 85 00:05:12,417 --> 00:05:13,319 They care very much. 86 00:05:13,499 --> 00:05:14,401 All three of them care. 87 00:05:14,621 --> 00:05:16,304 The Serbians are Serbian Orthodox. 88 00:05:16,885 --> 00:05:21,874 The Croatians are Roman Catholic. 89 00:05:22,455 --> 00:05:24,459 They hated each other at the beginning of that war. 90 00:05:24,719 --> 00:05:26,603 They killed each other at the beginning of that war. 91 00:05:26,923 --> 00:05:28,506 When did they stop killing each other? 92 00:05:29,802 --> 00:05:35,411 When they got together and decided it's more fun to kill Bosnians, because the Bosnians 93 00:05:35,470 --> 00:05:40,479 who look like the rest of you Caucasians and Europeans here, they look exactly like you. 94 00:05:40,504 --> 00:05:42,048 They are Europeans. 95 00:05:42,368 --> 00:05:43,511 What distinguishes them? 96 00:05:43,751 --> 00:05:44,974 They're not Orthodox. 97 00:05:45,254 --> 00:05:47,018 Is anybody here Orthodox? 98 00:05:47,268 --> 00:05:48,551 We have one Orthodox person. 99 00:05:48,611 --> 00:05:50,294 Anybody else belongs to an Orthodox Church? 100 00:05:51,076 --> 00:05:52,398 Nick, what one? 101 00:05:53,300 --> 00:05:54,743 Greek Orthodox Church. 102 00:05:55,003 --> 00:05:58,030 When did Orthodoxy... What is Orthodoxy? 103 00:05:58,651 --> 00:06:00,855 Here you're peeling the onion for the investors. 104 00:06:01,317 --> 00:06:07,189 The Orthodoxy is in 1054 when Christianity had split already into two geographic 105 00:06:07,248 --> 00:06:11,353 areas, one in Rome, a bishop in Rome, and a bishop in Constantinople. 106 00:06:11,694 --> 00:06:19,095 In 1054, after 700, 800 years of acrimony and separation of culture, one language was Latin, the other language 107 00:06:19,120 --> 00:06:26,674 was Greek, the two bishops simultaneously excommunicated each other and called each other Satan and the Antichrist. 108 00:06:27,254 --> 00:06:32,822 And that began a period of Christian killing Christian that went on, that went on until when? 109 00:06:33,122 --> 00:06:36,006 For centuries, and have they come together yet? 110 00:06:36,340 --> 00:06:39,532 No, they still hate each other and you can't get the Pope. 111 00:06:39,833 --> 00:06:46,738 The Pope cannot get an audience with the Greek patriarch until the Vatican apologizes for what, Nick? 112 00:06:48,473 --> 00:06:49,575 The Fourth Crusade. 113 00:06:50,157 --> 00:06:51,459 When was the Fourth Crusade? 114 00:06:52,080 --> 00:06:53,143 1204. 115 00:06:53,684 --> 00:06:54,526 That's memory. 116 00:06:55,468 --> 00:06:58,394 That's what you call memory, and that's what Americans don't have. 117 00:06:58,695 --> 00:06:59,797 Americans have no memory. 118 00:07:00,018 --> 00:07:02,222 The Europeans have memory they never forgot. 119 00:07:02,282 --> 00:07:06,752 The Battle of Kosovo was 1389. 120 00:07:06,732 --> 00:07:08,575 The Serbians never forget that. 121 00:07:08,835 --> 00:07:13,924 I said, you've got to know the culture of the people that you're going to invest with so that you don't make mistakes. 122 00:07:14,244 --> 00:07:16,067 So they found out, they learned a little bit about it. 123 00:07:16,087 --> 00:07:18,271 What do you mean, European Muslims, they were asking? 124 00:07:18,291 --> 00:07:19,673 There are no Muslims in Europe. 125 00:07:20,014 --> 00:07:25,703 I said, the Ottoman Empire left behind about a million three-quarter converts to Islam. 126 00:07:25,683 --> 00:07:29,269 that they look like the rest of the Europeans, but their religion is different. 127 00:07:29,289 --> 00:07:33,495 They're Muslim, they're Islamic, and there is perpetual eternal hate. 128 00:07:33,515 --> 00:07:37,602 Anyway, learning is what you have to can do, and it starts at commencement. 129 00:07:38,163 --> 00:07:41,929 We want to make certain that you continue with your lifelong learning along with your children. 130 00:07:42,329 --> 00:07:45,073 And thanks to email, it works. 131 00:07:45,093 --> 00:07:46,175 You get in touch with all of us. 132 00:07:46,576 --> 00:07:48,619 But you must keep learning. 133 00:07:48,699 --> 00:07:53,242 If you had graduated from medical school in 1950 and stopped pulling 134 00:07:53,266 --> 00:07:57,809 on your intellectual oars and no longer kept up, you would have missed 135 00:07:57,934 --> 00:08:02,776 90% of all the discoveries in basic biomedical science since the beginning 136 00:08:02,800 --> 00:08:07,244 of civilization, all of which have been made in the last 50 years. 137 00:08:07,924 --> 00:08:13,712 In science and in every other field of human understanding, it's lifelong learning or doom. 138 00:08:14,570 --> 00:08:15,771 I am not a scientist. 139 00:08:16,372 --> 00:08:18,054 I'm not a biomedical researcher. 140 00:08:18,154 --> 00:08:20,176 That's the basic theme for this weekend. 141 00:08:20,837 --> 00:08:26,406 I'm a humanist, a cultural historian, but I can tell you that it is essential 142 00:08:26,430 --> 00:08:31,399 to understand the cultural environment in which science and biomedical research 143 00:08:31,423 --> 00:08:37,638 grows, regardless of your spiritual, sectarian, or secular orientation 144 00:08:37,762 --> 00:08:42,842 no matter what your ideological, religious, or political point of view might be. 145 00:08:43,021 --> 00:08:48,356 To understand Galileo and his age, you have to examine the forces aligned in 146 00:08:48,380 --> 00:08:53,715 the 17th century with or against the Copernican theory of the solar system. 147 00:08:54,837 --> 00:09:02,367 At various times in history, the great scientific issues had to first confront questions of morality and custom. 148 00:09:02,988 --> 00:09:03,949 It's unavoidable. 149 00:09:04,992 --> 00:09:12,190 In 1796, Edward Jenner faced enormous moral hostility when he inoculated 150 00:09:12,215 --> 00:09:18,914 a nine-year-old boy with fluid from a cowpox pustule on a dairy maid's hand. 151 00:09:19,395 --> 00:09:25,383 Jenner had noted that milkmaids who developed cowpox, a much less serious disease 152 00:09:25,407 --> 00:09:31,894 did then not develop smallpox, the scourge of 18th century England. 153 00:09:32,802 --> 00:09:40,066 Six weeks later, he exposed the boy to smallpox and the boy did not develop any smallpox symptoms. 154 00:09:40,888 --> 00:09:45,664 Jenner coined the word vaccine from the Latin word vacca. 155 00:09:46,454 --> 00:09:48,357 because of its cowpox origins. 156 00:09:49,138 --> 00:09:53,121 When words spread to America about Jenna's vaccination, 157 00:09:53,145 --> 00:09:57,499 Timothy Dwight, a congregationalist minister and president 158 00:09:57,523 --> 00:10:05,661 of Yale University, proclaimed from the University Pulpit in New Haven that vaccination thwarted God's will. 159 00:10:05,641 --> 00:10:13,090 saying, quote, if God had decreed from all eternity that a certain person should die of smallpox, 160 00:10:13,114 --> 00:10:20,562 it would be a frightful sin to avoid and annul that decree by the trick of vaccination, unquote. 161 00:10:21,284 --> 00:10:28,504 Two years later, in 1798, several Boston clergymen and devout physicians stated that, quote 162 00:10:28,528 --> 00:10:35,747 the law of God prohibits the practice, unquote, and formed the anti-vaccination society in America. 163 00:10:36,308 --> 00:10:41,436 They demanded that doctors who carried out these procedures be tried for attempted murder. 164 00:10:42,547 --> 00:10:47,650 The 20th century has given historians of science, particularly in America, an opportunity 165 00:10:47,733 --> 00:10:53,536 to examine the special relationship between scientific investigation and community values. 166 00:10:54,427 --> 00:10:58,128 Many in this audience come from other parts of the world, yet all of you 167 00:10:58,152 --> 00:11:02,323 sitting out there today will be facing these issues for the rest of your lives. 168 00:11:03,125 --> 00:11:04,969 Most likely your children will as well. 169 00:11:05,911 --> 00:11:12,705 I single out the United States because of the unique and exceptional confluence of forces that have come together here. 170 00:11:13,647 --> 00:11:18,961 It was that canny young Frenchman, Alexis de Tocqueville, who first coined the 171 00:11:18,985 --> 00:11:24,783 word exceptional, "Exceptionnel" , to describe America in the 1830s when he visited. 172 00:11:24,803 --> 00:11:26,446 Do you remember why he came to visit this country? 173 00:11:27,707 --> 00:11:28,549 de Tocqueville came over. 174 00:11:28,569 --> 00:11:31,072 He was a young kid, really, in his early 20s. 175 00:11:31,413 --> 00:11:35,098 He came to an America to examine the penal system. 176 00:11:35,744 --> 00:11:36,485 Why? 177 00:11:37,041 --> 00:11:42,709 He said Americans, more than any other country in the world, seemed to lock their people up. 178 00:11:43,668 --> 00:11:44,369 Has that changed? 179 00:11:45,030 --> 00:11:47,734 No, we still incarcerate more people than anyone. 180 00:11:47,754 --> 00:11:53,744 In fact, what you discover as you evaluate yourself and look over American history, nothing really changes. 181 00:11:54,024 --> 00:11:59,050 De Tocqueville said, Americans start a new town, and the first thing they build are 182 00:11:59,074 --> 00:12:04,400 a church, a school, because they educate more people than anyone else, and a jail. 183 00:12:04,700 --> 00:12:05,722 That's what they build first. 184 00:12:05,962 --> 00:12:08,426 Those are the things that were most important to Americans. 185 00:12:08,586 --> 00:12:10,890 A church, a school, and a jail. 186 00:12:12,119 --> 00:12:16,815 When he described America as exceptional, he did not mean necessarily better. 187 00:12:17,417 --> 00:12:22,956 He just meant exceptional, different, and he said, filled with contradiction and paradox. 188 00:12:23,206 --> 00:12:26,318 He noted, in fact, if you get a chance, one of the assignments 189 00:12:26,342 --> 00:12:29,453 would be go home and get a good volume, a good edited volume. 190 00:12:29,954 --> 00:12:37,062 Harvey Mansfield's has just come out, a new one, an edited edition of Tocqueville's Democracy in America. 191 00:12:37,243 --> 00:12:42,028 It's a wonderful reading from the 1830s to see what this young Frenchman thought about this country. 192 00:12:42,068 --> 00:12:45,172 So it's great stuff to sit and put next to your bed or on the beach. 193 00:12:45,192 --> 00:12:46,173 It's just great reading. 194 00:12:46,554 --> 00:12:48,176 And you need some annotations. 195 00:12:48,368 --> 00:12:51,692 He noted that we were the most energetic 196 00:12:51,860 --> 00:12:57,547 charitable, creative, entrepreneurial, and he had used the word entrepreneurial, 197 00:12:57,571 --> 00:13:02,608 inventive, self-congratulatory, competitive people he had ever seen. 198 00:13:03,089 --> 00:13:07,641 He said, if you don't congratulate an American fast enough, they will congratulate themselves. 199 00:13:11,683 --> 00:13:17,081 And at the same time, they are the most religious, pious, intolerant, 200 00:13:17,347 --> 00:13:23,357 selfish, self-absorbed, greedy, and racist people he had ever encountered. 201 00:13:23,922 --> 00:13:26,385 What's more, he stated, these Americans have no memory. 202 00:13:27,166 --> 00:13:30,710 They are not interested in the past, only the future. 203 00:13:31,325 --> 00:13:36,632 What became known as the American paradox has become de Tocqueville's legacy for us. 204 00:13:36,897 --> 00:13:42,284 And we continue to study it today as we continue to examine ourselves 205 00:13:42,308 --> 00:13:48,310 and as the world attempts to pursue the vexing question to many of them, who are these Americans? 206 00:13:49,252 --> 00:13:52,183 To prepare you for your encounter with science this weekend 207 00:13:52,626 --> 00:13:55,626 Let me continue with your education into memory 208 00:13:55,977 --> 00:13:57,477 and American history. 209 00:13:57,977 --> 00:14:02,677 Galileo and Jenner were two scientists who reflected their societies' difficulties. 210 00:14:03,485 --> 00:14:04,761 Today in America 211 00:14:05,061 --> 00:14:10,067 You cannot pick up a newspaper or hit a blog without dealing with the societal 212 00:14:10,091 --> 00:14:15,096 issues of the morning after pill, stem cell research, genetic 213 00:14:15,120 --> 00:14:19,903 engineering, cloning, fertilization, creationism versus Darwinism, 214 00:14:19,927 --> 00:14:25,080 intelligent design, and a host of issues that will not be going away. 215 00:14:25,988 --> 00:14:28,772 In Boston, we have our own unique problems to confront. 216 00:14:29,413 --> 00:14:34,066 Boston University is building a gigantic federal laboratory in the midst of an 217 00:14:34,090 --> 00:14:39,107 urban neighborhood to investigate the most toxic and lethal poisons in the world. 218 00:14:39,668 --> 00:14:42,752 And the local people require attention and education. 219 00:14:43,273 --> 00:14:45,516 And so do the scientists working there. 220 00:14:45,698 --> 00:14:50,132 Our own Professor Sheldon Kribsky has been writing about how medical research being 221 00:14:50,156 --> 00:14:55,079 funded by corporate interests is corrupting health science research and drug development. 222 00:14:55,600 --> 00:15:01,092 Society and science will always be joined at the hip, so that's not going to be avoided. 223 00:15:02,303 --> 00:15:08,678 However, we now have come to a special moment, one that started more than 380 years ago when this country 224 00:15:08,702 --> 00:15:15,077 was settled by religious dissidents who believed that God gave them this land to prosper economically. 225 00:15:15,638 --> 00:15:23,355 The Puritan ethic that uniquely American combination of finding material prosperity in God's favor was the 226 00:15:23,379 --> 00:15:30,595 Protestant ethic that Max Weber spoke of more than two centuries later, and it is alive and well today. 227 00:15:31,075 --> 00:15:38,525 We are a nation of great religious awakenings that began almost immediately, and that religious passion 228 00:15:38,549 --> 00:15:45,999 has remained a hallmark of American values, particularly as we approach the millennium year of 2000. 229 00:15:46,399 --> 00:15:50,186 Religion is encoded in the American DNA. 230 00:15:50,566 --> 00:15:52,048 Just compare us to Europe. 231 00:15:53,029 --> 00:15:55,671 Why is this, by the way, if I may make a slight digression? 232 00:15:55,912 --> 00:16:00,662 Why do you think America is so... You go to a European chapel 233 00:16:00,686 --> 00:16:06,342 a European cathedral in France on Sunday, it's not only empty, it's vacant. 234 00:16:07,043 --> 00:16:07,824 Nobody's there. 235 00:16:08,244 --> 00:16:10,026 The Europeans have stopped going to church. 236 00:16:10,327 --> 00:16:13,110 The Europeans have stopped being observant. 237 00:16:13,130 --> 00:16:14,291 Why do you think this happened? 238 00:16:14,311 --> 00:16:17,434 And why is America more religious than ever before? 239 00:16:18,190 --> 00:16:19,793 Not ever before. It's always been this way. 240 00:16:19,903 --> 00:16:20,825 Nothing has changed. 241 00:16:21,416 --> 00:16:22,056 Why? 242 00:16:23,079 --> 00:16:29,294 How do you deal with this within the context of free enterprise 243 00:16:30,020 --> 00:16:32,898 which has always been an American thing also? 244 00:16:33,699 --> 00:16:40,131 What were these European religions in their countries after the 30 Years war, about which you should know a lot? 245 00:16:41,005 --> 00:16:42,566 What was the 30 Years' War? 246 00:16:42,767 --> 00:16:48,047 Luther had done his thing in 1517, a rather humorless German priest, a monk, and didn't 247 00:16:48,071 --> 00:16:53,658 like Rome, and he nailed up his 95 complaints against the Catholic Church on October 31st, 248 00:16:53,682 --> 00:16:59,236 1517, and then he sort of went back and forth, and then Luther died, but it really hit its 249 00:16:59,260 --> 00:17:05,127 head, the struggle between Catholicism and Protestantism after Protestantism got established. 250 00:17:05,147 --> 00:17:08,650 1618, the whole thing boiled over, and you had a war that lasted. 251 00:17:09,372 --> 00:17:11,334 30 years, that's the name of it, the 30 years war. 252 00:17:11,555 --> 00:17:13,697 It was the war of unbelievable brutality. 253 00:17:13,958 --> 00:17:20,066 It was, we talked about the first great schism between Western Catholicism and Eastern Catholicism Orthodoxy. 254 00:17:20,346 --> 00:17:25,352 This was the second great schism that really just rented Christianity apart. 255 00:17:25,693 --> 00:17:31,941 It was between Protestantism and Catholicism and as often the case in religious wars like this, 256 00:17:32,221 --> 00:17:33,443 It was brutal. 257 00:17:33,503 --> 00:17:40,574 The Protestant armies invading Catholic cities, they cut off the arms of all the Catholic men, float them down the river. 258 00:17:40,915 --> 00:17:45,110 Protestant armies invading, Catholic armies invading Protestant cities, or vice versa, 259 00:17:45,134 --> 00:17:49,328 they go and cut off all the legs of the other people that float them down the river. 260 00:17:49,529 --> 00:17:50,450 It was barbarity. 261 00:17:51,031 --> 00:17:53,295 And they finally settled it in 1648. 262 00:17:53,715 --> 00:17:54,837 How did they settle it? 263 00:17:56,217 --> 00:17:56,878 How did they settle? 264 00:17:56,898 --> 00:17:58,160 How did the Europeans settle their religion? 265 00:17:58,180 --> 00:17:59,361 What is Europe like religiously? 266 00:17:59,722 --> 00:18:01,825 Supposedly, we settled by the rulers. 267 00:18:02,145 --> 00:18:07,572 The rulers said, what we are, you are. 268 00:18:08,213 --> 00:18:16,925 So Southern German rulers said, we're Catholic, and anybody who wants to live here will be Catholic. 269 00:18:16,945 --> 00:18:20,089 The Northern German rulers said, we're Protestant. 270 00:18:20,169 --> 00:18:22,633 Anybody who wants to live here will be Protestant. 271 00:18:22,673 --> 00:18:24,435 Scandinavian countries said, 272 00:18:25,141 --> 00:18:25,942 We're Protestant. 273 00:18:26,322 --> 00:18:28,585 Austria said, we're Catholic. 274 00:18:28,665 --> 00:18:30,647 Italy said, we're Catholic. 275 00:18:30,667 --> 00:18:32,649 Spain said, we're Catholic. 276 00:18:32,669 --> 00:18:34,511 France said, we're Catholic. 277 00:18:34,612 --> 00:18:36,854 England said, screw you all. 278 00:18:38,636 --> 00:18:41,459 England said, Henry V said it back in the 16th. 279 00:18:41,499 --> 00:18:43,581 Henry VIII said it in the 16th century. 280 00:18:43,802 --> 00:18:44,823 He said, I don't like Rome. 281 00:18:45,063 --> 00:18:46,164 I don't like the Protestants. 282 00:18:46,405 --> 00:18:47,706 I'm making the 283 00:18:47,905 --> 00:18:49,669 church of England. 284 00:18:50,551 --> 00:18:53,678 So he stiffed them all and did his own thing all together. 285 00:18:54,720 --> 00:18:56,083 People wanted to be Catholic. 286 00:18:56,364 --> 00:19:01,836 Elizabeth barely saved her life, got her out with her life because Mary wanted to be- she was Catholic and so on. 287 00:19:02,016 --> 00:19:03,459 But what happened in America? 288 00:19:03,479 --> 00:19:05,822 So what did you have in Europe? 289 00:19:05,842 --> 00:19:10,748 You had a religion imposed by the state. 290 00:19:10,948 --> 00:19:12,931 Who supported religion in Europe? 291 00:19:13,287 --> 00:19:14,047 The state. 292 00:19:14,072 --> 00:19:14,813 It gave money. 293 00:19:15,034 --> 00:19:16,617 You had schools. 294 00:19:16,776 --> 00:19:17,977 You learned religion in schools. 295 00:19:18,298 --> 00:19:19,940 And what did the ministers have to do? 296 00:19:21,091 --> 00:19:21,831 Nothing. 297 00:19:22,220 --> 00:19:23,181 They did nothing. 298 00:19:23,324 --> 00:19:25,507 They knew that they were supported by the state. 299 00:19:25,787 --> 00:19:27,149 And eventually it just wore out. 300 00:19:27,169 --> 00:19:28,491 The people didn't give a damn anymore. 301 00:19:28,771 --> 00:19:30,113 What about the United States? 302 00:19:31,291 --> 00:19:33,696 You had no official state religion. 303 00:19:33,937 --> 00:19:35,480 No official state religion. 304 00:19:35,500 --> 00:19:36,964 That was one thing. That's that separation. 305 00:19:37,184 --> 00:19:38,828 Nothing is ever going to be official. 306 00:19:39,008 --> 00:19:40,812 We're going to be a religious nation. 307 00:19:41,053 --> 00:19:42,115 We're a Christian nation. 308 00:19:42,396 --> 00:19:43,639 But nothing official. 309 00:19:43,839 --> 00:19:45,503 So what do the ministers have to do? 310 00:19:46,276 --> 00:19:46,997 They had to hustle. 311 00:19:47,598 --> 00:19:48,800 They were competitive. 312 00:19:48,820 --> 00:19:54,769 If this Baptist church made it, he would take away from that Baptist church, and that Baptist church went down. 313 00:19:55,170 --> 00:20:00,458 So it was dog eat dog among this free enterprise system of religion in America. 314 00:20:00,638 --> 00:20:02,741 This shoal made it, that shoal broke away. 315 00:20:03,082 --> 00:20:04,404 It either made it or didn't. 316 00:20:04,424 --> 00:20:06,147 Catholic churches closed. 317 00:20:06,167 --> 00:20:09,772 Tufts just bought the Catholic church on the corner of Winthrop Avenue. 318 00:20:09,885 --> 00:20:10,585 We bought it. 319 00:20:10,634 --> 00:20:12,657 It's now got two Tufts flags in front of it. 320 00:20:12,837 --> 00:20:14,299 Because the Catholic Church, why? 321 00:20:14,320 --> 00:20:17,204 The Catholic Church couldn't make a go of it. 322 00:20:17,505 --> 00:20:20,470 So the fates have to hustle, and so it's competitive. 323 00:20:20,851 --> 00:20:24,517 It is religion by competition, religion as free enterprise. 324 00:20:24,537 --> 00:20:27,622 And it works in this country, and it kept working in the people. 325 00:20:28,143 --> 00:20:28,884 That's what they want. 326 00:20:29,125 --> 00:20:32,630 I mean, how do Americans, how do Americans fund things? 327 00:20:32,650 --> 00:20:34,153 How do Americans fund things? 328 00:20:35,787 --> 00:20:36,948 Charity, what do we call it? 329 00:20:36,968 --> 00:20:37,589 Philanthropy? 330 00:20:37,669 --> 00:20:38,190 Charity? 331 00:20:38,871 --> 00:20:41,333 How much philanthropy does America give a year? 332 00:20:41,694 --> 00:20:46,379 Americans give over $300 billion of philanthropy a year. 333 00:20:46,599 --> 00:20:49,563 The Europeans wouldn't know a foundation if they fell into one. 334 00:20:49,823 --> 00:20:51,365 They don't have foundations in Europe. 335 00:20:51,665 --> 00:20:55,009 Americans make laws of taxes so that you can give charitably. 336 00:20:55,209 --> 00:20:58,573 When the tsunami hit, what was the first thing President Bush did? 337 00:20:59,074 --> 00:21:02,638 He sent his father and the previous president. 338 00:21:02,872 --> 00:21:10,308 Clinton and First Bush went on the road and raised $400 million - millions of dollars in the United States, 339 00:21:10,332 --> 00:21:14,868 much more than the government gave because people in the United States believe in charity. 340 00:21:14,987 --> 00:21:17,775 Why? They don't trust 341 00:21:18,616 --> 00:21:19,518 government. 342 00:21:19,538 --> 00:21:24,628 They don't want government in their face, and so they rather give it themselves and they do it themselves. 343 00:21:24,808 --> 00:21:27,313 So it's two different worlds when it comes to religion. 344 00:21:27,634 --> 00:21:31,060 America is, as de Tocqueville said, exceptionnel. 345 00:21:31,080 --> 00:21:32,543 They are just different. 346 00:21:32,938 --> 00:21:35,503 So as we enter the 20th century, 347 00:21:35,599 --> 00:21:39,665 As we entered the 20th century, 100 years ago, when we came into that turn of 348 00:21:39,690 --> 00:21:45,456 the century, 1900, American Christianity was already particularly muscular. 349 00:21:45,685 --> 00:21:47,567 It was a muscular Christianity. 350 00:21:47,908 --> 00:21:51,866 Within a few years, or decades, the Dayton, Tennessee monkey trials, 351 00:21:51,890 --> 00:21:56,321 which pitted Darwin against the Bible, that was as American as apple pie. 352 00:21:56,401 --> 00:22:00,207 If you ever saw the movie, Inherit the Wind, or read the novel, that's America. 353 00:22:00,427 --> 00:22:02,190 Tennessee was a state that said what? 354 00:22:04,482 --> 00:22:05,425 Anybody from Tennessee? 355 00:22:05,727 --> 00:22:07,614 What was the law of the land? 356 00:22:07,955 --> 00:22:10,324 States' rights and the state had the right to say what? 357 00:22:12,512 --> 00:22:15,302 The teaching of Darwin is 358 00:22:15,721 --> 00:22:16,322 illegal. 359 00:22:16,482 --> 00:22:17,563 It's against the law. 360 00:22:17,803 --> 00:22:19,064 So that was it. 361 00:22:19,385 --> 00:22:24,748 We are a nation of God-fearing people, self-reliant in our attitudes, and to this day, more 362 00:22:24,772 --> 00:22:30,075 than half the American population believes that the world is less than 6,000 years old. 363 00:22:30,636 --> 00:22:35,561 Over half the American people believe that the world is less than 6,000 years old. 364 00:22:35,821 --> 00:22:37,943 The biblical span of humanity. 365 00:22:39,550 --> 00:22:41,833 Observing Jews just welcomed the New Year. 366 00:22:41,987 --> 00:22:42,808 What year was it? 367 00:22:44,324 --> 00:22:46,226 5767. 368 00:22:46,410 --> 00:22:47,814 We haven't reached 6,000 yet. 369 00:22:48,021 --> 00:22:49,584 5767. 370 00:22:49,800 --> 00:22:50,682 What does that reflect? 371 00:22:51,625 --> 00:22:52,427 What does it reflect? 372 00:22:52,447 --> 00:22:53,691 The 5767. 373 00:22:56,178 --> 00:22:58,063 How do you get to 5767? 374 00:22:59,073 --> 00:23:07,201 How do you get to a date that Jerry Falwell, the president of Iran and the chief rabbi of Israel would agree on? 375 00:23:07,602 --> 00:23:13,247 The only thing in history they would agree on, but they would agree on 5767. 376 00:23:13,908 --> 00:23:17,011 Why? You've got to go back before. 377 00:23:17,672 --> 00:23:18,593 Where do you find the number? 378 00:23:18,633 --> 00:23:19,594 How do you get to the number? 379 00:23:19,814 --> 00:23:21,475 You're not reading your what? 380 00:23:21,976 --> 00:23:22,817 What are you not reading? 381 00:23:23,077 --> 00:23:25,359 I don't care if you have faith or not, that's not the issue. 382 00:23:26,040 --> 00:23:29,063 Though faith is your own private business, but what do you got to know? 383 00:23:29,870 --> 00:23:32,202 You gotta know the Hebrew Bible. 384 00:23:34,122 --> 00:23:37,187 The Christian Bible and the Quran. 385 00:23:37,687 --> 00:23:40,792 I mean, there are more references to Abraham in the Quran. 386 00:23:40,952 --> 00:23:43,997 There are almost as many references to Abraham in the Quran as there are to Muhammad. 387 00:23:44,838 --> 00:23:47,202 Jesus is a prophet in the Quran. 388 00:23:47,823 --> 00:23:50,226 John the Baptist is a prophet in the Quran. 389 00:23:50,587 --> 00:23:53,311 They are honored patriarchs of their faith. 390 00:23:53,731 --> 00:23:59,260 Abraham is called the first Muslim because he was the first person to submit to the will of God. 391 00:23:59,520 --> 00:24:01,163 Now, why, I mean, people, 392 00:24:01,443 --> 00:24:05,207 Christians, Jews, believe that God and Allah are two different people. 393 00:24:05,268 --> 00:24:05,948 They are not. 394 00:24:06,209 --> 00:24:08,111 Because what's the problem? 395 00:24:08,651 --> 00:24:09,332 It's language. 396 00:24:09,993 --> 00:24:10,654 It's language. 397 00:24:10,894 --> 00:24:14,302 When you hear someone say, there is only one God and His name is 398 00:24:14,326 --> 00:24:18,223 Allah, that gives you the impression that God and Allah are different. 399 00:24:18,243 --> 00:24:22,708 But in the original Arabic, the word for God and the word for Allah, 400 00:24:23,127 --> 00:24:24,068 is the same word. 401 00:24:24,449 --> 00:24:29,495 So what the Arabic really says is there is only one God and his name is God. 402 00:24:29,996 --> 00:24:31,558 But that's monotheism. 403 00:24:31,778 --> 00:24:35,203 There is only one God and they accept the God of Abraham. 404 00:24:35,243 --> 00:24:37,806 They accept the God of Jesus. 405 00:24:38,166 --> 00:24:42,172 They accept, I mean, Jesus is not the reincarnation of God. 406 00:24:42,192 --> 00:24:44,274 He is the prophet of Christianity. 407 00:24:44,314 --> 00:24:49,773 So these faiths are tied together, and this magical date of 5767 reflects 408 00:24:49,797 --> 00:24:55,788 all the generations in the book of Genesis since not Abraham, but since Adam. 409 00:24:56,070 --> 00:24:56,990 Since Adam. 410 00:24:57,109 --> 00:25:01,236 You add them all up, all the begettans and all the begottens, and 411 00:25:01,260 --> 00:25:05,839 you get George Gershwin, who's the oldest person in the Hebrew Bible? 412 00:25:06,140 --> 00:25:07,782 George Gershwin wrote about him. 413 00:25:07,913 --> 00:25:09,095 Methuselah, how long do you live? 414 00:25:09,316 --> 00:25:12,682 Methuselah lived 900 years. 415 00:25:12,982 --> 00:25:14,385 Methuselah lived 900 years. 416 00:25:14,405 --> 00:25:16,729 So you add it all up and you get to this year. 417 00:25:16,949 --> 00:25:19,895 You got to go to your Hebrew Bible and add them up. 418 00:25:19,955 --> 00:25:23,521 This is probably, as I said, the only date that these people could get to agree on. 419 00:25:23,824 --> 00:25:27,110 You examine the history of scientific accomplishments 420 00:25:27,168 --> 00:25:30,350 in the first half of the 20th century, particularly in 421 00:25:30,374 --> 00:25:33,556 biomedical research, and who was at the front of it? 422 00:25:33,877 --> 00:25:36,740 Who led the world from 1850 to 1950? 423 00:25:37,682 --> 00:25:39,424 Heads and shoulders above everything. 424 00:25:41,927 --> 00:25:49,136 When the Nobel prizes started getting announced at the end of the 19th century, who's getting them? 425 00:25:49,156 --> 00:25:52,601 France gets a few- Curie and a few others. 426 00:25:53,110 --> 00:25:54,271 Pasteur. 427 00:25:54,860 --> 00:25:57,304 Who gets the majority from 1900 on? 428 00:25:57,836 --> 00:25:58,557 The Germans. 429 00:25:58,586 --> 00:26:02,031 But it's the Europeans with French and then German hegemony. 430 00:26:02,051 --> 00:26:07,019 They're the ones who are leading, not only just biomedical, but also in physics. 431 00:26:07,260 --> 00:26:10,224 The European generation of Albert Einstein led the way. 432 00:26:10,485 --> 00:26:16,154 For Americans like Robert Oppenheimer, there was only one place to study, Europe, particularly Germany. 433 00:26:16,490 --> 00:26:21,378 And the Nobel Prize Committee, selection committee, only validated that fact of European 434 00:26:21,522 --> 00:26:26,269 and German hegemony in the century following 1850. 435 00:26:26,605 --> 00:26:30,810 The letter to President Roosevelt that urged America to develop 436 00:26:30,834 --> 00:26:35,039 an atomic bomb was drafted by one European and signed by another. 437 00:26:35,664 --> 00:26:40,291 Without the European scientists at Los Alamos, they would not have been an American atomic bomb. 438 00:26:40,852 --> 00:26:47,582 The three great discoverers of penicillin, who won the Nobel Prize in 1945, were all Europeans. 439 00:26:48,744 --> 00:26:49,605 What changed it all? 440 00:26:50,767 --> 00:26:52,727 World War II changed it all. 441 00:26:52,893 --> 00:26:56,827 It brought to the world stage an age of extraordinary scientific 442 00:26:56,851 --> 00:27:01,223 accomplishment that pushed societal values to the back of the stage. 443 00:27:01,944 --> 00:27:06,469 It also destroyed European leadership and brought American science to the forefront. 444 00:27:06,930 --> 00:27:13,967 When Francis Crick, an Englishman, collaborating in 1950 with the American James Watson, raced into a 445 00:27:13,991 --> 00:27:21,027 pub in Cambridge, England, he declared excitedly, quote, we've discovered the secret of life, unquote. 446 00:27:21,115 --> 00:27:25,181 It was not spiritual, not God-inspired or creationist. 447 00:27:25,552 --> 00:27:30,301 The secret of life for the unredemptingly secular Crick and 448 00:27:30,326 --> 00:27:35,568 the somewhat lecherous Watson was in the double helix and DNA. 449 00:27:36,329 --> 00:27:40,635 The secret of life for them was to be found in chemistry and physics. 450 00:27:41,223 --> 00:27:47,411 Then followed the enormous breakthroughs of Jonas Salk and Albert Sabin in eradicating infantile paralysis. 451 00:27:47,912 --> 00:27:54,641 Sputnik was in that mix also, and science came forward and pushed everything off the stage. 452 00:27:55,482 --> 00:28:01,482 In the 50 years since the end of the Second World War, we have defeated smallpox 453 00:28:01,506 --> 00:28:07,298 German measles, and a host of other diseases that were the terror of the developed world. 454 00:28:07,497 --> 00:28:11,343 America has clearly become the leader in medical science investigation. 455 00:28:11,864 --> 00:28:16,812 And if you happen to examine the recent Nobel awards in science and economics, we still are. 456 00:28:17,372 --> 00:28:19,155 The only one we didn't win was the Peace Prize. 457 00:28:19,997 --> 00:28:24,584 And that went to an, interesting enough, an Indian economist, who they gave the Peace Prize to. 458 00:28:25,926 --> 00:28:28,951 And so we're still leading in scientific investigation. 459 00:28:28,971 --> 00:28:35,040 There were also ample second generation Americans, the grandchildren of immigrants among those recipients. 460 00:28:35,020 --> 00:28:39,566 But now as we enter the 21st century, there are other and different challenges. 461 00:28:40,267 --> 00:28:43,131 The secularism of the 50s and the 60s is over. 462 00:28:43,531 --> 00:28:44,733 That's my generation. 463 00:28:45,314 --> 00:28:51,602 We were a secular college generation, which is one of the interesting problems of teaching for people my age. 464 00:28:52,423 --> 00:28:55,786 They were trained, whether they were trained in the 60s or 465 00:28:55,810 --> 00:28:59,172 the 50s and the 60s at places like Berkeley, at Michigan, 466 00:28:59,152 --> 00:29:03,755 at Stanford, at Harvard, and we were brought up in that scientific 467 00:29:03,779 --> 00:29:09,163 environment where science was on top of everything and science triumphant. 468 00:29:09,223 --> 00:29:11,865 Some of my particular generation might remember those 469 00:29:11,889 --> 00:29:15,450 strange-looking people standing on the street corners of our cities. 470 00:29:15,871 --> 00:29:19,971 In the 1950s, I remember seeing one when I played hooky from high school 471 00:29:19,995 --> 00:29:23,980 and went to the Paramount to see Jimmy Dorsey playing on the stage. 472 00:29:24,145 --> 00:29:27,028 Frank Sinatra was still singing with him. 473 00:29:27,063 --> 00:29:32,651 There was a guy in the corner in a brown rag with a long beard and hair down to his shoulders. 474 00:29:32,991 --> 00:29:35,675 And he was holding a sign that said, prepare yourself. 475 00:29:38,058 --> 00:29:40,542 The end of the world is near. 476 00:29:41,363 --> 00:29:43,786 The end of the world, 1952, prepare yourself. 477 00:29:43,806 --> 00:29:44,888 The end of the world is near. 478 00:29:45,709 --> 00:29:46,771 Prepare yourself for what? 479 00:29:46,871 --> 00:29:49,815 We left either out of embarrassment or mockery. 480 00:29:49,835 --> 00:29:54,161 If he were there on that same corner today, what would his message read? 481 00:29:54,401 --> 00:29:56,344 Probably, I told you so. 482 00:29:57,252 --> 00:29:59,996 because it's a different time and a different age. 483 00:30:00,437 --> 00:30:05,265 We are living certainly in the United States in an age of spiritual self-discovery, and 484 00:30:05,289 --> 00:30:10,511 once again the values of science and the values of faith are facing off against each other. 485 00:30:11,052 --> 00:30:16,816 There is a search right now for what we are called anti-poverty vaccines to combat 486 00:30:16,840 --> 00:30:23,030 parasitic and bacterial illnesses that are not only caused by poverty, but also perpetuate it. 487 00:30:23,510 --> 00:30:27,052 We're not talking about illnesses in the developed nations of the world 488 00:30:27,076 --> 00:30:30,617 but rather tropical diseases that affect billions of people. 489 00:30:31,058 --> 00:30:38,145 One alone, Hookworm, has infected 576 million people in the developing nations of the tropics. 490 00:30:38,986 --> 00:30:43,451 But the barriers of finding vaccines for these diseases are not scientific. 491 00:30:44,011 --> 00:30:50,698 They are cultural, social, political, and religious, particularly in the case of HIV-AIDS. 492 00:30:51,370 --> 00:30:56,617 The world thought that it had seen the last of the dreadful disease infantile paralysis, polio. 493 00:30:57,318 --> 00:31:00,963 No more children with shriveled limbs, living lives in iron lungs. 494 00:31:01,724 --> 00:31:05,950 But a week ago, the Wall Street Journal, and I didn't find it in any other newspaper. 495 00:31:06,231 --> 00:31:11,158 I saw it not reported anywhere else except in the Wall Street Journal, announced in a very brief 496 00:31:11,693 --> 00:31:18,880 news announcement that polio had been diagnosed again in Kenya, the first case in 22 years. 497 00:31:19,754 --> 00:31:25,921 but the 26th nation reinfected by a 2003 vaccine boycott by 498 00:31:25,945 --> 00:31:32,112 people who considered vaccination, quote, satanic, unquote. 499 00:31:32,132 --> 00:31:37,519 So it's coming back because in one year, people refused their children vaccination. 500 00:31:39,322 --> 00:31:43,651 When he received the Nobel Prize in 1952, Albert Schweitzer 501 00:31:43,675 --> 00:31:47,854 said, quote, you don't live in a world alone, unquote. 502 00:31:48,053 --> 00:31:50,700 More than 50 years later, his words are truer than ever. 503 00:31:51,523 --> 00:31:57,118 The world has grown smaller and smaller, has always grown and has also grown more dangerous. 504 00:31:57,217 --> 00:32:02,664 Today, diseases halfway around the planet can affect us sitting here in a matter of days. 505 00:32:03,445 --> 00:32:06,128 It's become a fact of everyday existence. 506 00:32:06,148 --> 00:32:12,362 The recent example of toxic spinach infected by E. coli bacteria has led London 507 00:32:12,404 --> 00:32:18,341 bookmakers to make odds on which vegetable will carry the next contaminant. 508 00:32:19,419 --> 00:32:21,682 Mushroom leads at six to one. 509 00:32:23,701 --> 00:32:24,504 That's true. 510 00:32:25,002 --> 00:32:26,511 The British will bet on anything. 511 00:32:27,174 --> 00:32:30,936 And they're betting on which vegetable will be contaminated next. 512 00:32:32,570 --> 00:32:38,457 So as you go forth on your scientific adventure over the next few years, whether you're a scientist, laypeople, 513 00:32:38,481 --> 00:32:44,368 humanists, no matter what your field of endeavor is, no matter what it is, I leave you with only one thought. 514 00:32:45,029 --> 00:32:47,813 Science will not succeed or fail in a vacuum. 515 00:32:48,494 --> 00:32:53,076 The history of scientific discovery and progress are inseparable from 516 00:32:53,100 --> 00:32:58,088 the cultural forces that ought to cheer on or inhibit these discoveries. 517 00:32:58,113 --> 00:33:02,485 And here in the United States, those cultural forces have always been formidable. 518 00:33:02,941 --> 00:33:05,809 I take no political or ideological position. 519 00:33:06,170 --> 00:33:08,536 That's something that we as faculty have had to learn. 520 00:33:09,097 --> 00:33:11,925 You come up to a certain line and you don't cross it. 521 00:33:12,175 --> 00:33:19,620 There are students on our in our classes of deep faith we don't you go in there and think- either denigrate 522 00:33:19,644 --> 00:33:26,955 or not denigrate your job is to get up to the line cause whatever stimulation you can and then you step back from it 523 00:33:26,979 --> 00:33:33,149 you don't cross a line. The debates on Darwinism or Darwin, Stan Bennett's new book on 524 00:33:33,174 --> 00:33:41,294 breaking the spell which is unredemptively atheistic those are things that we you you just 525 00:33:41,673 --> 00:33:45,355 You allow your class to vet in any way that it wants, and you don't insinuate 526 00:33:45,379 --> 00:33:49,060 your own positions into these things, and no teacher has the right to do that. 527 00:33:49,400 --> 00:33:51,943 I take no political or ideological position. 528 00:33:52,463 --> 00:34:00,714 All I say to you is this, inform yourselves, educate yourselves, make intelligent decisions based on science, your faith, 529 00:34:00,944 --> 00:34:04,557 and humanity, because they cannot be separated from 530 00:34:04,581 --> 00:34:08,664 one another, and for the rest of your lives, they never will be. 531 00:34:08,736 --> 00:34:09,536 Thank you. 532 00:34:14,731 --> 00:34:23,591 I kept it as short as I could, only for the idea that the best parts are always the arguments, the debates, the discussions. 533 00:34:23,631 --> 00:34:26,337 If you want to have any, let's go at it any way you'd like. 534 00:34:28,763 --> 00:34:29,685 Yes, please. 535 00:34:29,863 --> 00:34:32,207 [Audience Member] What should we know about the Shiites and Sunnis? 536 00:34:32,282 --> 00:34:39,853 Well, each of the religions had, as soon as they, the three religions of Abraham are the problem, perplexing. 537 00:34:40,282 --> 00:34:45,359 And if you read 1491, the book about what happened, it was obvious that those 538 00:34:45,410 --> 00:34:49,663 Native Americans were killing each other also, for some reason or other. 539 00:34:49,788 --> 00:34:54,255 The secular scientists, the secular biologists, hold onto the question. 540 00:34:54,470 --> 00:34:57,214 The secular biologists say that 541 00:34:57,239 --> 00:35:05,149 Mankind, if you want to be that sexist, mankind is destined to fulfill its biological destiny. 542 00:35:05,549 --> 00:35:10,636 And what is the biological destiny of mankind, says secular scientists? 543 00:35:11,837 --> 00:35:15,990 Because we are a naked ape, we are an aggressive naked ape, we are 544 00:35:16,014 --> 00:35:20,167 destined by every stretch of our imagination to kill ourselves off. 545 00:35:20,648 --> 00:35:25,474 And we will blow this world up because what do we have bigger than any other species? 546 00:35:26,635 --> 00:35:31,366 We got the brain, technology will advance, and technology will be our undoing. 547 00:35:32,108 --> 00:35:34,918 The world was once destroyed by flood, say the three 548 00:35:34,942 --> 00:35:37,641 religions of Abraham, it will next be destroyed 549 00:35:38,380 --> 00:35:44,246 They say, they agree, in the Koran, in the Hebrew Bible, in the Christian Bible, by fire. 550 00:35:44,867 --> 00:35:49,390 And David Koresh, when he killed himself and those 90 people 551 00:35:49,414 --> 00:35:53,936 in 1993 in Waco, Texas, said, come on in, just come on in. 552 00:35:54,316 --> 00:35:56,378 Because he wanted a self-fulfilling prophecy. 553 00:35:56,618 --> 00:35:58,881 He was, as he said, who did he say he was? 554 00:36:01,083 --> 00:36:03,325 Koresh, just like James Jones. 555 00:36:03,997 --> 00:36:05,339 He was the Messiah. 556 00:36:05,359 --> 00:36:06,480 He was the second coming. 557 00:36:06,740 --> 00:36:07,601 He was Messiah. 558 00:36:07,802 --> 00:36:12,427 He said, not only am I the second coming to the Christians, I am the first coming for the Jews. 559 00:36:12,868 --> 00:36:16,272 And I will be the coming of end time for Islam. 560 00:36:16,292 --> 00:36:19,896 I am the embodiment of faith for all three religions. 561 00:36:20,417 --> 00:36:23,460 And he had followers, just as James Jones had followers. 562 00:36:23,721 --> 00:36:28,905 And he took his 900 followers down to Guyana and convinced the adults 563 00:36:28,984 --> 00:36:33,368 to give the children Kool-Aid laced with cyanide and killed them all. 564 00:36:33,393 --> 00:36:34,474 So why do they kill them all? 565 00:36:35,355 --> 00:36:36,276 Because they all believe. 566 00:36:36,336 --> 00:36:38,078 Why didn't Koresh care? 567 00:36:38,098 --> 00:36:41,422 Why didn't they even suicide bombers, even though people say they're so well educated? 568 00:36:42,363 --> 00:36:43,704 There are other circumstances. 569 00:36:43,985 --> 00:36:45,927 Or they may be well educated, but what do they all believe in? 570 00:36:47,168 --> 00:36:47,909 They all have faith. 571 00:36:48,309 --> 00:36:50,352 They are blessed with the gift of faith. 572 00:36:50,752 --> 00:36:54,511 They believe that their faith will get them to sit at 573 00:36:54,535 --> 00:36:58,801 the right hand of Allah, or God, or Mashiach, or Messiah. 574 00:36:59,281 --> 00:37:00,683 In Greek it's called what, Nick? 575 00:37:02,047 --> 00:37:06,272 Christos, it's Christos, it's Messiah, it's Messiah. 576 00:37:06,332 --> 00:37:07,313 You gotta open your mind. 577 00:37:07,333 --> 00:37:09,436 You told me you were Greek Orthodox, now I'm gonna nail you. 578 00:37:10,377 --> 00:37:18,388 And so, faith, each of those religions, but coupled with aggression, causes each of those 579 00:37:18,441 --> 00:37:23,180 religions to split and get aggressive against anybody who is different than they are. 580 00:37:23,272 --> 00:37:27,317 On the Boston Common, there is a monument to a woman named Mary Dyer. 581 00:37:27,697 --> 00:37:29,200 Mary Dyer was a Quaker. 582 00:37:29,721 --> 00:37:32,647 In 1660, the Puritans hanged her. 583 00:37:33,128 --> 00:37:36,975 Before they hanged her, they nailed her tongue to the roof of her mouth, so she couldn't speak. 584 00:37:37,516 --> 00:37:41,083 Because Quakerism was considered Satan. 585 00:37:41,564 --> 00:37:43,748 Now, who do they worship? 586 00:37:45,490 --> 00:37:46,311 Christ. 587 00:37:46,507 --> 00:37:47,449 They were all Christians. 588 00:37:48,070 --> 00:37:51,315 But Roger Williams got thrown out of a Massachusetts colony 589 00:37:51,339 --> 00:37:54,583 and Hutchinson got thrown out of the Massachusetts colony. 590 00:37:54,884 --> 00:37:56,527 They find reasons to hate each other. 591 00:37:56,808 --> 00:37:59,293 Eastern Orthodoxy, Western Roman Catholicism. 592 00:37:59,614 --> 00:38:02,119 What happened with Islam was the same thing. 593 00:38:02,400 --> 00:38:04,303 They're all Muslims. 594 00:38:04,623 --> 00:38:06,405 They all worship Allah. 595 00:38:06,926 --> 00:38:10,281 But within two generations after the death of Muhammad, 596 00:38:10,305 --> 00:38:14,035 there was a battle over which way the succession would go. 597 00:38:14,575 --> 00:38:19,509 Would it be the family of Ali, who was the son-in-law and nephew of Muhammad, 598 00:38:19,533 --> 00:38:24,467 and it would follow down hasidically through the generations of the family? 599 00:38:24,548 --> 00:38:25,510 And Ali said, yes. 600 00:38:26,071 --> 00:38:31,179 And then Ali got murdered by a group of people who said, no, it should be the great priests of the faith. 601 00:38:31,820 --> 00:38:37,850 The priests of the faith were called Sunni, and the followers of Ali were called Shi'i. 602 00:38:39,092 --> 00:38:40,594 Are they the same faith? 603 00:38:41,155 --> 00:38:43,119 Yeah, they all worship Islam. 604 00:38:43,139 --> 00:38:46,410 But for twelve, thirteen, fourteen hundred years now 605 00:38:46,434 --> 00:38:50,050 they have hated each other and kill each other in the name of God. 606 00:38:50,738 --> 00:38:53,080 Sigmund Freud had said a lot that was wrong. 607 00:38:53,120 --> 00:38:54,402 Freud was no great scientist. 608 00:38:54,622 --> 00:38:56,103 He was just a great sociologist. 609 00:38:56,484 --> 00:39:01,489 And he said, he's had an idea that he called the narcissism of minor difference. 610 00:39:02,230 --> 00:39:07,055 That people who are very much alike, like the Serbians and the Croatians, will hate each other. 611 00:39:08,076 --> 00:39:15,463 And they will kill each other until they come together and find somebody else they hate. 612 00:39:16,456 --> 00:39:18,060 And so they stopped killing each other. 613 00:39:18,240 --> 00:39:20,605 You know, there was an article in the New York Times about a year ago. 614 00:39:20,946 --> 00:39:26,298 They interviewed a Southern Italian peasant and asked him, how do you feel about the common market? 615 00:39:26,779 --> 00:39:27,561 The European Union. 616 00:39:27,821 --> 00:39:29,064 How do you feel about the European Union? 617 00:39:29,465 --> 00:39:33,233 He said, the European Union, I hate the people in the next valley. 618 00:39:34,900 --> 00:39:37,322 What do you care about the European Union? 619 00:39:37,342 --> 00:39:39,064 When I got somebody that close I can hate? 620 00:39:39,564 --> 00:39:40,125 What do I care? 621 00:39:40,820 --> 00:39:42,002 Why do they hate the people in the next valley? 622 00:39:42,027 --> 00:39:43,648 It's a slightly different dialect. 623 00:39:43,668 --> 00:39:45,990 They worshiped another saint, honored another saint. 624 00:39:46,411 --> 00:39:51,435 And how do you get those two people in the two valleys to come together and hate somebody else? 625 00:39:51,836 --> 00:39:52,576 Show them a Roman. 626 00:39:53,557 --> 00:39:54,138 Hate the Roman. 627 00:39:54,318 --> 00:39:56,920 How do you get the Southern Italians to come together? 628 00:39:57,481 --> 00:39:59,723 Show them a Northern Italian. They hate them. 629 00:39:59,743 --> 00:40:01,525 How do you get all the Italians to come together? 630 00:40:01,825 --> 00:40:04,047 Show them an Austrian from the Tirol. 631 00:40:04,482 --> 00:40:08,112 And that's what Freud called the narcissism of minor difference. 632 00:40:08,132 --> 00:40:11,322 How do you get the Shi'i and the Sunni to stop killing each other? 633 00:40:12,377 --> 00:40:13,443 Right now you can't. 634 00:40:13,488 --> 00:40:15,193 Right now they're killing each other big time. 635 00:40:15,574 --> 00:40:17,198 Somebody will come up with a brilliant idea. 636 00:40:17,820 --> 00:40:18,863 Let's kill. 637 00:40:19,231 --> 00:40:23,901 Americans, or Christians, or Jews, or somebody else. 638 00:40:24,182 --> 00:40:26,768 But right now, those two faiths are at each other. 639 00:40:26,888 --> 00:40:29,694 So all you need to know technically is how they were established. 640 00:40:30,175 --> 00:40:33,021 They were created either simply through the line of succession. 641 00:40:33,242 --> 00:40:35,847 I mean, are Protestants and Catholics Christians? 642 00:40:36,749 --> 00:40:37,932 Yeah. 643 00:40:38,654 --> 00:40:41,177 You know, or Eastern Orthodox and Western Orthodox, forget it. 644 00:40:41,337 --> 00:40:43,339 But look what happened to Protestantism in the United States. 645 00:40:43,619 --> 00:40:45,161 How many Protestant groups do we have? 646 00:40:45,581 --> 00:40:46,842 Separate churches and sects. 647 00:40:47,183 --> 00:40:47,923 6,000. 648 00:40:48,924 --> 00:40:49,605 6,000. 649 00:40:49,845 --> 00:40:54,750 The biggies, you know, you got, I mean, how did Presbyterianism break away from the Methodists? 650 00:40:54,830 --> 00:40:56,372 Presbyterianism, they just broke away. 651 00:40:56,672 --> 00:40:57,914 So this is the nature. 652 00:40:58,274 --> 00:41:01,017 As I said, the breakaway shoal, the breakaway synagogue. 653 00:41:01,377 --> 00:41:03,720 Everybody's got to have something somebody they can hate. 654 00:41:04,180 --> 00:41:05,962 Now, what did the secular scientists say? 655 00:41:06,162 --> 00:41:08,104 That only is the innate 656 00:41:08,675 --> 00:41:11,359 Conrad Lorenz wrote a book about 50 years ago. 657 00:41:11,980 --> 00:41:14,263 The German title was Das Ogen an der Bürse. 658 00:41:14,763 --> 00:41:19,770 The so-called, he called it, and the English translation was On Aggression. 659 00:41:20,852 --> 00:41:26,239 And he was a behaviorist, and he talked about, and he was secular, very secular, anti-religious. 660 00:41:26,560 --> 00:41:29,063 He said, this is, we're just a naked ape. 661 00:41:29,195 --> 00:41:30,217 We're just a naked ape. 662 00:41:30,497 --> 00:41:38,131 We didn't have the idea of a god when we were on all fours, when we were quadrupleds, and we had a tail and pointed ears. 663 00:41:38,431 --> 00:41:43,300 But then when we got developed as a human species, then we discovered what? 664 00:41:43,660 --> 00:41:45,664 Our own mortality. 665 00:41:45,784 --> 00:41:46,906 And we didn't like that at all. 666 00:41:47,467 --> 00:41:48,369 So what came next? 667 00:41:50,172 --> 00:41:52,536 These are the very secular people. 668 00:41:52,634 --> 00:41:55,060 came next in our mindset, God. 669 00:41:55,461 --> 00:41:57,786 So they are direct challenges to faith. 670 00:41:58,027 --> 00:41:59,009 People of faith have it. 671 00:41:59,209 --> 00:42:03,680 People without faith come up for the reasons why there should be no faith. 672 00:42:03,700 --> 00:42:07,391 And yet they all acknowledge, well, they don't acknowledge aggression 673 00:42:07,415 --> 00:42:10,997 because what do all three of those religions of Abraham profess? 674 00:42:11,956 --> 00:42:13,698 at one point or other, all three of them. 675 00:42:14,118 --> 00:42:15,680 What do they want? Ultimately, they want peace. 676 00:42:16,020 --> 00:42:20,341 We will take our swords, bang them into plowshares, says Isaiah, 677 00:42:20,365 --> 00:42:24,411 but that was, whether he said that before or after, Joshua went into 678 00:42:24,435 --> 00:42:29,684 Canaan when Moses died and the God speaks to Joshua and 679 00:42:29,808 --> 00:42:32,957 says in the book of Joshua, my servant Moses is dead. 680 00:42:33,158 --> 00:42:38,503 I want you now to go and take the rest of Canaan, kill everybody and go up to the river. 681 00:42:39,664 --> 00:42:40,545 It's not Jordan. 682 00:42:41,605 --> 00:42:47,620 The river, what river is mentioned in that little talk that God gives to Joshua? 683 00:42:47,640 --> 00:42:51,148 Take the Israelites up to the banks of the river, Euphrates. 684 00:42:52,151 --> 00:42:53,554 He takes them up to the Euphrates. 685 00:42:53,915 --> 00:42:55,639 People read that today and what do they say? 686 00:42:56,822 --> 00:42:57,724 Prophecy. 687 00:42:58,193 --> 00:42:58,974 It's prophecy. 688 00:42:59,759 --> 00:43:03,583 So the whole idea of the millennial age, the prophetic age, it has all of 689 00:43:03,623 --> 00:43:07,446 these three religions coming together saying this is a momentous moment. 690 00:43:07,866 --> 00:43:14,393 Remember, Woodrow Wilson and Lloyd George, the people who put together the Treaty of Versailles, or tried to 691 00:43:14,417 --> 00:43:20,944 put together the Treaty of Versailles, they were the sons of born-again evangelical Presbyterian ministers. 692 00:43:21,380 --> 00:43:24,062 Lloyd George's father was born again. 693 00:43:24,102 --> 00:43:26,324 Woodrow Wilson's father was born again. 694 00:43:26,384 --> 00:43:32,009 Evangelicalism in 1900 in that first 25 years was extraordinary explosive. Why? 695 00:43:33,150 --> 00:43:35,993 Why did Americans, Europeans believe this is the time? 696 00:43:36,013 --> 00:43:38,855 1900 to 1920, 1930. 697 00:43:39,004 --> 00:43:41,166 It was the beginning of what century? 698 00:43:42,278 --> 00:43:45,401 The last century before the millennium. 699 00:43:45,681 --> 00:43:49,885 What was the other last century before the millennium a thousand years before that? 700 00:43:52,447 --> 00:43:56,511 Well, it would be the year 1000, the year 1000. 701 00:43:56,872 --> 00:44:00,516 Nothing happened in that year, and they were predicting God is coming back. 702 00:44:00,536 --> 00:44:01,977 Christ will come back, for sure. 703 00:44:01,997 --> 00:44:05,100 1095, Jesus hadn't come back yet. 704 00:44:05,681 --> 00:44:07,703 Pope Urban II says, I know why. 705 00:44:08,812 --> 00:44:15,660 The Holy Land is occupied by the infidel, by Islam. 706 00:44:15,752 --> 00:44:19,315 When we clear the Holy Land of the infidel, Christ will return. 707 00:44:19,736 --> 00:44:20,817 What began? 708 00:44:21,218 --> 00:44:22,561 200 years of the Crusades. 709 00:44:23,362 --> 00:44:28,406 When World War I ended and Lloyd George and Woodrow Wilson had an opportunity 710 00:44:28,430 --> 00:44:32,941 to do something that would fulfill their faith, what was that act? 711 00:44:33,863 --> 00:44:37,270 The idea of the Jewish people 712 00:44:38,735 --> 00:44:41,279 returning to the Holy Land. 713 00:44:41,619 --> 00:44:46,978 That is a primal piece of Christian evangelicalis 714 00:44:47,132 --> 00:44:51,504 that Christ will return when the Jews first return to the Holy Land. 715 00:44:51,634 --> 00:44:54,486 So the idea of the Jewish state that came out of the 716 00:44:54,510 --> 00:44:57,923 Balfour Declaration was a very important piece of all that. 717 00:44:58,104 --> 00:45:01,589 So these, I'll go back to your question, they will find a reason to hate each other. 718 00:45:01,769 --> 00:45:03,616 individually, inside the religions. 719 00:45:03,938 --> 00:45:06,668 The guy who killed Rabin said, I didn't kill Rabin. 720 00:45:06,709 --> 00:45:07,632 The Jew killed Rabin. 721 00:45:07,672 --> 00:45:10,142 He did it. He said, wow, whose hand was it? 722 00:45:10,274 --> 00:45:12,877 It was God's hand, these suicide bombers. 723 00:45:13,158 --> 00:45:15,361 They said, oh, Allah wants me to do this. 724 00:45:15,461 --> 00:45:16,302 I'm going to do it. 725 00:45:17,163 --> 00:45:22,470 Jews, Christians, Muslims, it's been part of the tradition for 2,000 years. 726 00:45:22,911 --> 00:45:27,016 And they all want peace, but it somehow comes out more aggressively than that. 727 00:45:27,076 --> 00:45:31,262 And yet, when the event comes, what's it going to be like? 728 00:45:31,502 --> 00:45:36,409 I don't know if any of you have read any of the swept away novels, the rapture novels of LaHaye and Jenkins. 729 00:45:36,802 --> 00:45:38,604 Anybody read any of them at all? 730 00:45:38,692 --> 00:45:42,999 That tells you something, because they've sold 60 million copies in the United States. 731 00:45:43,440 --> 00:45:46,586 60 million copies have been sold in the United States. 732 00:45:46,606 --> 00:45:47,647 13 novels. 733 00:45:47,988 --> 00:45:51,194 And they are novels of the rapture, people being swept away. 734 00:45:51,815 --> 00:45:57,943 Jerry Falwell says, if you are a born-again person 735 00:45:57,967 --> 00:46:01,832 and you are driving along, make sure that there is a Jew at the wheel of your car. 736 00:46:01,912 --> 00:46:04,604 because when the rapture comes, you'll be swept away. 737 00:46:04,664 --> 00:46:07,397 The Jews will be left to fight Satan for a thousand years. 738 00:46:07,678 --> 00:46:08,743 He's a premillennialist. 739 00:46:09,104 --> 00:46:11,736 And at the end of that thousand years, they will accept Christ. 740 00:46:12,104 --> 00:46:15,629 So that's the job, to make sure there's a Jew driving, because he'll be able to keep 741 00:46:15,653 --> 00:46:19,476 driving the car else the car will, people will get killed and they shouldn't get killed. 742 00:46:19,496 --> 00:46:22,501 Well, it's faith, it's the belief in it. 743 00:46:22,802 --> 00:46:26,147 And so, the time right now, what are we waiting for? 744 00:46:26,167 --> 00:46:27,670 What are people waiting for? 745 00:46:28,090 --> 00:46:31,589 If they're waiting for the second coming or the first coming, because there are 746 00:46:31,638 --> 00:46:38,193 Orthodox Jews near Shareem, looking at red heifers, counting every hair in a red heifer, 747 00:46:38,648 --> 00:46:46,618 Because the Book of Numbers says, when a red heifer is born without one white hair, Mashiach is coming. 748 00:46:47,399 --> 00:46:50,483 We've got a Chabad House off campus. 749 00:46:50,503 --> 00:46:54,228 The Chabad Movement, which is Lubavitch and Hasidic, the 750 00:46:54,252 --> 00:46:58,793 Lubavitcher Movement believes that Rabbi Schneerson was Mashiach. 751 00:46:58,813 --> 00:47:03,267 He died eight or nine, 10 years ago, but in the Tufts newspaper the other day, there 752 00:47:03,291 --> 00:47:07,744 was an ad that said, come have Friday night dinner with us and help Mashiach come. 753 00:47:08,180 --> 00:47:15,899 So that the high idea of the return, whether it's the Tokyo gassings that were there by a Muslim sect called end timers, 754 00:47:16,123 --> 00:47:23,342 the end of time, or whether it's Jew, Christian, Muslim, if you are a person of deep faith, what are you waiting for now? 755 00:47:24,805 --> 00:47:25,686 What are you waiting for now? 756 00:47:25,706 --> 00:47:26,708 The time is ripe. 757 00:47:26,928 --> 00:47:28,390 There's chaos in the Middle East. 758 00:47:28,670 --> 00:47:30,373 There's chaos around the world. 759 00:47:30,944 --> 00:47:34,046 There are people being murdered, there's suicide, there's everything 760 00:47:34,070 --> 00:47:37,172 going on, it's anarchy, chaos, tsunami, everything's going wrong. 761 00:47:37,433 --> 00:47:39,215 Earthquake, what are you waiting for? 762 00:47:40,377 --> 00:47:43,381 You're waiting for Armageddon, and there's another word, too. 763 00:47:44,122 --> 00:47:47,466 The apocalypse, Armageddon, and what will happen? 764 00:47:47,546 --> 00:47:50,769 It'll be violent, it'll be the end of time, but at the end 765 00:47:50,793 --> 00:47:54,015 of that violence, at the end of time, what will we have? 766 00:47:54,552 --> 00:47:56,215 We'll have God's kingdom established on earth. 767 00:47:56,916 --> 00:48:01,482 So you go where your heart and your mind and your faith take you, 768 00:48:01,566 --> 00:48:05,332 but inside each of the three religions of Abraham is conflict. 769 00:48:05,952 --> 00:48:10,340 Then outside is conflict because they all see it as God's ultimate design. 770 00:48:11,021 --> 00:48:14,647 Then you got the secular, godless, and they're in there pitching away too. 771 00:48:15,284 --> 00:48:16,165 What do I do? 772 00:48:16,190 --> 00:48:17,472 I play with my grandchildren. 773 00:48:18,633 --> 00:48:21,336 at hope that my grandchildren live to have grandchildren. 774 00:48:21,416 --> 00:48:25,762 Because there's no guarantee, one way or the other, that the world can hold together. 775 00:48:26,082 --> 00:48:29,266 Somebody wants to string together 60 nuclear devices around the world. 776 00:48:29,446 --> 00:48:30,928 We'll have the technology to do that. 777 00:48:31,449 --> 00:48:33,151 What are we going to have in 50 years? 778 00:48:33,512 --> 00:48:38,598 The next generation of technology people are going to be bright. 779 00:48:38,938 --> 00:48:39,960 It's going to be explosive. 780 00:48:39,980 --> 00:48:40,801 It's exponential. 781 00:48:41,181 --> 00:48:42,683 So they will know they'll be able to do. 782 00:48:43,043 --> 00:48:45,346 People will be able to get their hands on anything. 783 00:48:45,647 --> 00:48:48,370 The nuclear proliferation treaty looks like it's gone. 784 00:48:48,412 --> 00:48:50,715 So that everybody's going to have the bomb and it'll be available. 785 00:48:51,014 --> 00:48:52,175 And then we'll see what happens. 786 00:48:52,937 --> 00:48:55,721 I'll be in Century Village if I'm still around doing macrame. 787 00:48:55,896 --> 00:48:56,496 Yes? 788 00:48:58,144 --> 00:49:00,708 [Audience Member] Just switching a little bit topic to something you touched on. 789 00:49:00,748 --> 00:49:05,100 Let's say over the next 50 or 100 years, stem cell research 790 00:49:05,124 --> 00:49:09,400 can create new human beings, eradicate lots of disease. 791 00:49:09,961 --> 00:49:13,352 Do you think that government and religion around the world will, 792 00:49:13,376 --> 00:49:16,891 that some will embrace or will they all be against the development? 793 00:49:17,071 --> 00:49:20,858 It'll be up to the- Europeans will go one way right now there are some 794 00:49:20,882 --> 00:49:24,557 Americans that are leaving to do research in Europe or it'll 795 00:49:24,581 --> 00:49:28,734 depends how the Indians how the Chinese- the Chinese if they remain secular 796 00:49:28,758 --> 00:49:32,583 if they're Chinese remain atheistic if that's what they can pull off 797 00:49:32,663 --> 00:49:41,133 If they stay Marxist in that sense of no God, there'll be no inhibitions on their research. 798 00:49:41,554 --> 00:49:43,416 The rest of the world, I can't tell you. I don't know. 799 00:49:43,456 --> 00:49:49,343 That'll be political scientists and better cultural historians than I am who will know which way that will go. 800 00:49:49,544 --> 00:49:51,406 The Europeans right now have no inhibitions. 801 00:49:52,344 --> 00:49:57,190 It all depends on how each nation responds to that particular phenomenon. 802 00:49:57,232 --> 00:50:00,861 But there'll be social forces at work 803 00:50:00,886 --> 00:50:05,165 to either advocate, prevent, or the Chinese are interesting in terms of their faith. 804 00:50:05,646 --> 00:50:08,565 What are the three religions of China that really, when you, you know, 805 00:50:08,589 --> 00:50:11,976 Chinese say that it's atheist country, but you're not stopping certain things? 806 00:50:12,898 --> 00:50:13,719 What are the three biggies? 807 00:50:14,192 --> 00:50:14,993 Buddhism? 808 00:50:15,942 --> 00:50:17,284 Taoism? 809 00:50:17,669 --> 00:50:22,598 Confucianism, all agnostic, they're all speculative religions. 810 00:50:23,019 --> 00:50:25,784 They all say, well, you can do this, you can do that. 811 00:50:26,065 --> 00:50:28,509 They don't have the big capital A answer. 812 00:50:28,890 --> 00:50:33,757 The only ones that have the answer are Judaism, Christianity, and Islam that have 813 00:50:33,781 --> 00:50:38,648 this sense of deep abiding faith, abiding faith, and their belief in what they are. 814 00:50:38,737 --> 00:50:43,305 Each one says this is the way it's sequenced, but our faith is the true faith. 815 00:50:43,730 --> 00:50:47,756 So you wonder, and the Chinese have never been that aggressive. 816 00:50:48,004 --> 00:50:52,772 They've taken Tibet, and that's interesting that they grabbed Tibet, but they never grabbed anything else. 817 00:50:53,132 --> 00:50:56,097 What happens to the rest of the world tends to do what? Grab? 818 00:50:57,376 --> 00:51:02,610 China, they tend to grab pieces of China in the 18th century when the British sent the gunboats 819 00:51:02,634 --> 00:51:07,867 up the Pearl River and the Chinese at that time had nothing but junks with fireworks on them. 820 00:51:08,167 --> 00:51:12,168 They shot off fireworks, the British blew them out of the water with a cannon 821 00:51:12,192 --> 00:51:16,194 and that was the beginning of who came with the British Army and navy 822 00:51:17,218 --> 00:51:23,944 missionaries, who followed, who came with the Spanish soldiers in Latin America in the 15th century. 823 00:51:24,647 --> 00:51:25,348 Priests. 824 00:51:25,662 --> 00:51:26,603 So they come. 825 00:51:26,624 --> 00:51:30,709 And Christianity had its great moment of expansion. 826 00:51:30,989 --> 00:51:31,851 They had the armies. 827 00:51:32,512 --> 00:51:33,593 The Jews, nothing. 828 00:51:33,673 --> 00:51:36,096 They didn't have any armies from the time of Jesus on. 829 00:51:36,417 --> 00:51:37,198 They had no armies. 830 00:51:37,598 --> 00:51:38,800 So the Jews weren't a force. 831 00:51:39,060 --> 00:51:40,262 Christianity was the force. 832 00:51:40,382 --> 00:51:44,248 And the other one that was created in the 7th century, Islam. 833 00:51:44,468 --> 00:51:45,830 They were the two that had the armies. 834 00:51:46,090 --> 00:51:47,532 And they were the ones that spread. 835 00:51:48,575 --> 00:51:50,458 So, what's going to happen? 836 00:51:50,478 --> 00:51:52,262 But it's always in the name of God. 837 00:51:52,582 --> 00:51:53,965 It was always war in the name of God. 838 00:51:54,185 --> 00:51:57,912 When the Israelites went around Jericho, what were they carrying? 839 00:52:00,176 --> 00:52:03,763 They walked around the walls of Jericho carrying the Ark of the Covenant. 840 00:52:04,060 --> 00:52:04,761 It says so. 841 00:52:05,025 --> 00:52:06,267 They carry the Ark of the Covenant. 842 00:52:06,307 --> 00:52:09,553 Walls come tumbling down, and then what did they do? 843 00:52:10,732 --> 00:52:12,215 They killed every man, woman, and child. 844 00:52:12,616 --> 00:52:15,943 Killed everybody in Jericho and I the next time they did it again. 845 00:52:16,424 --> 00:52:18,347 It's simply the way it was. 846 00:52:19,072 --> 00:52:19,894 Yeah? 847 00:52:20,211 --> 00:52:24,079 I had a question about the convergence of religion and science today. 848 00:52:24,099 --> 00:52:29,550 It seems that humanity had a little bit of a protective factor in the last 50 years that 849 00:52:30,155 --> 00:52:32,938 religion and science weren't so closely related. 850 00:52:33,078 --> 00:52:34,519 Now they seem to be kind of closer together. 851 00:52:34,539 --> 00:52:35,260 I wonder if you can comment. 852 00:52:35,280 --> 00:52:40,071 Well, I think I did, in the sense that secular period, that period from right after 853 00:52:40,095 --> 00:52:44,769 World War II to 25, 30 years ago, it was, we didn't notice what was happening. 854 00:52:45,049 --> 00:52:51,994 We didn't notice that Billy Graham, those that were secular, but 1950s, along with Watson and Crick and Sabin and 855 00:52:52,018 --> 00:52:55,878 Salk and Sputnik, Billy Graham had started the Crusades 856 00:52:55,903 --> 00:52:58,863 for Christ and they were already filling up auditoriums. 857 00:52:58,943 --> 00:53:02,886 How is it now that a guy with the technology to build a bomb can decide 858 00:53:02,910 --> 00:53:06,852 that it's a good idea to give it to a religious fundamentalist group? 859 00:53:07,613 --> 00:53:08,755 Well, that's the other part of it. 860 00:53:08,875 --> 00:53:10,136 How is that happening? 861 00:53:10,156 --> 00:53:11,218 Well, will it happen? 862 00:53:11,658 --> 00:53:13,280 The Pakistanis will sell it around. 863 00:53:13,500 --> 00:53:14,341 Will the North Koreans? 864 00:53:14,382 --> 00:53:15,823 It'll get around. It'll proliferate. Why? 865 00:53:16,044 --> 00:53:17,025 Because there are two instincts. 866 00:53:17,325 --> 00:53:17,906 There's faith. 867 00:53:18,186 --> 00:53:20,429 And there's the other thing I said in terms of the Protestant ethic. 868 00:53:20,669 --> 00:53:23,733 There's the desire to make money. 869 00:53:24,374 --> 00:53:27,297 Now, I mean, who is the largest arms producer in the world? 870 00:53:28,981 --> 00:53:29,382 US. 871 00:53:30,163 --> 00:53:30,864 We're number one. 872 00:53:31,088 --> 00:53:33,245 And if you look at the other six or seven or eight countries, 873 00:53:33,286 --> 00:53:35,371 the Wall Street Journal publishes an article every year. 874 00:53:35,651 --> 00:53:37,053 But we're number one. Who's number two? 875 00:53:37,614 --> 00:53:39,036 I think it still is Great Britain. 876 00:53:39,617 --> 00:53:41,179 The Russians now are moving up fast. 877 00:53:41,219 --> 00:53:42,261 The French are right up there. 878 00:53:42,661 --> 00:53:47,749 It's the developed nations of the world that are the most 879 00:53:47,729 --> 00:53:52,598 acquisitive in terms of selling technology to these other nations. 880 00:53:52,618 --> 00:53:58,187 They're just, but they're non-nuclear, and they may call the weapons of, not weapons of mass destruction 881 00:53:58,211 --> 00:54:03,580 but you know, and F-16 can be a pretty deadly weapon, and we sell a lot of stuff. 882 00:54:03,760 --> 00:54:08,410 So the arms proliferation around the world, when you've got second banana, third banana, 883 00:54:08,434 --> 00:54:12,977 fourth banana countries buying guns and buying weapons that are very sophisticated. 884 00:54:13,458 --> 00:54:17,003 I mean, Brazil is selling right up there in the top eight in selling arms now 885 00:54:17,027 --> 00:54:20,571 around the country because they're making cheaper and more effective weapons. 886 00:54:20,912 --> 00:54:23,343 The Israelis sell more light submachine guns around 887 00:54:23,367 --> 00:54:25,501 the world than any other country in the world. 888 00:54:25,681 --> 00:54:30,806 So that the countries, the arms race will- mass destruction, that's something else. 889 00:54:30,866 --> 00:54:34,811 You just link up 30 or 40 bombs, and you can blow the earth out of its orbit. 890 00:54:35,652 --> 00:54:36,392 And that's possible. 891 00:54:37,053 --> 00:54:39,135 I'm not a scientist, so I don't know how possible. 892 00:54:39,155 --> 00:54:42,387 But linking up bombs like this and detonating them 893 00:54:42,411 --> 00:54:45,642 simultaneously is probably feasible within 25 years. 894 00:54:46,003 --> 00:54:47,144 The world is not the same. 895 00:54:47,424 --> 00:54:51,268 As we approach the year 2000, things change. 896 00:54:51,288 --> 00:54:54,051 And we're going to stay in this change for at least another 100 years. 897 00:54:54,959 --> 00:54:55,960 That's not going to go away. 898 00:54:55,980 --> 00:54:57,882 The religious implication will not go away. 899 00:54:57,902 --> 00:54:58,407 Yes, sir. 900 00:54:58,432 --> 00:55:01,032 [Audience Member]Is the era of State religion, is it over? 901 00:55:02,688 --> 00:55:04,009 No, I don't want to say Europe. 902 00:55:04,329 --> 00:55:05,331 It failed in Europe. 903 00:55:06,488 --> 00:55:07,151 I don't know. 904 00:55:07,206 --> 00:55:10,106 Looking at the world, do you predict the same shifts worldwide? 905 00:55:10,196 --> 00:55:12,118 You know, it's a question of maturity. 906 00:55:12,358 --> 00:55:16,623 It's a question of how long it takes a religion to mature as a state religion. 907 00:55:17,604 --> 00:55:20,207 Europe has been a state religion since when? 908 00:55:20,390 --> 00:55:23,334 since Constantine, since the third century. 909 00:55:23,654 --> 00:55:30,844 It took 16, 1700 years for Christianity really to become not a force in Europe. 910 00:55:32,306 --> 00:55:33,127 These other. 911 00:55:33,861 --> 00:55:36,905 [Audience Member] I bring up the heir of the Majapahit Empire of India. 912 00:55:37,613 --> 00:55:39,896 It certainly was very expansive at that point in Indonesia. 913 00:55:40,056 --> 00:55:43,741 It was a little in- as well as Malaysia the largest population of Muslims in the world. 914 00:55:44,322 --> 00:55:46,925 And that was a state religion at that time. 915 00:55:47,132 --> 00:55:51,484 I'm wondering if you predicted that era is over now we will enter an entrepreneurial 916 00:55:51,837 --> 00:55:54,627 No, no, no, I think you're extrapolating too much from what I said. 917 00:55:55,355 --> 00:55:57,338 I said that it's over in Europe. 918 00:55:57,358 --> 00:55:58,900 The Europeans have had it. 919 00:55:59,882 --> 00:56:02,545 I don't think, no, at least they've had it up until right now. 920 00:56:03,006 --> 00:56:05,818 Maybe religion will make a comeback, but everybody was 921 00:56:05,842 --> 00:56:08,974 shocked when they appointed another European as the Pope. 922 00:56:09,635 --> 00:56:11,878 They thought, where are they going to appoint somebody from? 923 00:56:12,719 --> 00:56:15,945 They'll appoint a pope from where Catholicism is growing. 924 00:56:16,227 --> 00:56:18,223 And where is Catholicism growing? 925 00:56:18,389 --> 00:56:20,913 Latin America, Africa, and Europe. 926 00:56:21,353 --> 00:56:22,675 I mean in Latin America and Asia. 927 00:56:22,742 --> 00:56:23,431 Please. 928 00:56:23,456 --> 00:56:25,443 [Audience Member] It's interesting, then, that the French government 929 00:56:25,485 --> 00:56:30,145 is actually supporting the building of new mosques in France. 930 00:56:31,027 --> 00:56:35,386 So if you were to extrapolate on that, then maybe in a generation, 931 00:56:35,410 --> 00:56:39,299 the Muslims in France would get tired of their religion. 932 00:56:39,319 --> 00:56:40,500 It would take one generation. 933 00:56:40,621 --> 00:56:41,682 It'll take longer than that. 934 00:56:41,902 --> 00:56:43,705 But the French are very political. 935 00:56:43,785 --> 00:56:48,826 I mean, this rule-law just now on saying that anybody who professes that you can't say, 936 00:56:48,850 --> 00:56:54,361 talk about the Armenian slaughter without using the G word, genocide, that's very political. 937 00:56:54,722 --> 00:56:58,808 So they will do things, I mean, you know, this goes back a long way. 938 00:56:59,129 --> 00:57:02,975 Richelieu was the great Catholic cardinal of 17th century France. 939 00:57:03,335 --> 00:57:04,918 Who did he support in the 30 Years war? 940 00:57:05,178 --> 00:57:05,859 The Protestants. 941 00:57:06,500 --> 00:57:09,625 The French are deliciously diabolical. 942 00:57:10,060 --> 00:57:12,225 in their politics, in their politics. 943 00:57:12,245 --> 00:57:16,273 They are capable of subtleties of European politics that are wonderful. 944 00:57:18,518 --> 00:57:19,660 Okay, I'm going to let you go. 945 00:57:19,680 --> 00:57:20,883 You got other things to go. 946 00:57:20,983 --> 00:57:21,825 Thank you very much.